The same should be true of those whose duties include looking after our infrastructure. The Russian ship, Aleksandr Suvorov, a river cruise ship 445 feet long and almost 4000 tons, plowed into a bridge support at Ulynaovsk on the Volga River because of going through the wrong part of the bridge. Submitted by TJ (not verified) on Mon, 07/13/2020 - 10:06pm, very good article and I agree with most of the prior comment. © 2017 Robinson Communications Inc. All Rights Reserved. As the repairs are being effected some key parts of evidence of what caused the failure could be changed or lost. Is this a design flaw? Our thoughts and prayers remain with Joe’s family and friends.” Even before the implementation of the bus lane, Metro buses were always operating in either the SR 99 on ramp lane or the one just to the left. Chris Arkills from Metro said, “Service began on the C Line on September 29, 2012. Lacey V. Murrow Bridge (I-90 Floating Bridge), 1990. The Highway 99 Klineline Bridge over Salmon Creek in Vancouver, Wash. was originally built in 1927. Submitted by Geoff Taylor (not verified) on Mon, 07/13/2020 - 5:18pm. The firm’s engineering design work was repeatedly criticized at the hearing. The chain ferry that links Cowes and East Cowes had been off since a piece of pipework on the east prow failed, causing the service to be cancelled last night. Over the course of several hours, the bridge sank to the bottom of the lake. It’s also worth noting that to build the very same style existing bridge today would cost in excess of $480 million. It was a poor design, poor management, and now a poor failure analysis. The lessons learned from the failure of the original Lacey V. Murrow Bridge are very valuable to the engineering community which, through the design of two new floating bridges across Lake Washington, has advanced the state of the art of floating bridge analysis, design, materials selection, and construction. The bridge took alot of hits, Submitted by Mark Ondrake (not verified) on Sat, 12/19/2020 - 8:30am. How you don't see the utter incompetence of the Mayor, City Council, and SDOT, makes the voice of an elder statesmen, useless. Eight years ago SDOT and Metro added a seventh lane for transit and the fully loaded C Line buses and other transit to use. Mohiuddin Ali Khan Ph.D., M.Phil., DIC, P.E., in Accelerated Bridge Construction, 2015. Most failures, particularly in facilities that have been in use for many years, result from multiple causes involving errors in design, construction, material deficiencies, and/or maintenance. Bridge overload and lateral impact forces from trucks, barges/ships, and trains constitute 20% of the total bridge failures.”, The West Seattle Bridge is another example of What Barry LePatner, author of Too Big to Fall - America’s Failing Infrastructure and the Way Forward (2010) says is a $2.2 trillion repair bill across the nation. Floating bridge timeline: 13 May - Vessel launched EDIT: Also if it helps, the term floating bridge actually refers to the point that it actually 'floats' in the brdige cavity on the guitar, this is so it can have full tonal pitch shift. The author of Why Buildings Fail, Ken Carper Professor Emeritus, Washington State University, Past National Chair of ASCE Forensic Engineering Division. But any new structure will need to meet a 2500 year standard, or a 9.0 quake. A traditional bridge is the most popular type of dental bridge and can be used when you have natural teeth on both sides of the gap created by your missing tooth. If Seattle doesn't require a independent investigation our federal govt should before they hand over any money on something that could fail again, Submitted by Peter Vanderzee (not verified) on Tue, 07/14/2020 - 4:57am. Were engineering studies done to look at the load rating for the bridge that confirmed it could take that kind of weight? Flood and scour, with the major flood disaster in 1993, contributed to the frequency peak of bridge failures (almost 53% of all failures). You'll simply need to keep this in mind and take precautions accordingly. From the Nisqually earthquake (which moved the bridge 3 inches), to concrete “creep” a kind of shrinkage that naturally occurs, to the failure of the bearing at Pier 18 which limited the ability of the bridge to flex. Our thoughts and prayers remain with Joe’s family and friends.” Having such a system in place now is worthwhile, but deploying it in 2020 is years too late. The southern tip of Harbor Island happens to be where the Seattle Fault passes through. Forensic engineering is the application of engineering principles to the investigation of failures or other performance problems. SDOT has thus far said a mix of things may be involved. This additional weight factor can make them more difficult to keep in place. What is the state’s plan to protect incarcerated people from Covid-19? A traditional bridge is the most popular type of dental bridge and can be used when you have natural teeth on both sides of the gap created by your missing tooth. Heavy rain and flooding caused this bridge to collapse in the Caribbean port city of La Ceiba, Honduras, on Nov. 4. Submitted by Shane (not verified) on Mon, 07/13/2020 - 8:09pm. The survey, which I filled out, mainly served to shame those of us who have daily vehicle needs for work (and/or are small business owners without access to resources like a shuttle, which I also am) by offering only ridesharing and public commute interventions. They’ve created a short term repair plan to address the immediate (and possibly longer term) stability of the span and put that plan into motion. Sad. The authority said £515,000 costs had been incurred so far because of the loss of income from the failed floating bridge, built by Mainstay Marine. This event led to the beginnings of state and county bridge inspection programs. We remain committed to constantly improving our safety program on the SR 520 Floating Bridge — and all of our projects. The failed bridges included everything from spans designed to carry pedestrians over roadways to floating pontoon bridges across lakes. Floating bridges however add another twist to the mix: the floating bridge itself is designed to be able to move parallel to the direction of the strings by swivelling on a pivot. It is 7,497 feet (2,285 meters), or 1.4 miles (metric), long and spans Lake Washington, letting vehicles pass to and from Seattle and Bellevue, Washington. The opportunities for learning these lessons should not be overlooked. Floating bridge timeline: 13 May - … But frivolous fun takes a backseat to the more utilitarian purposes that floating bridges serve. d) Keep in mind that the weight of a dental bridge may make it hard to keep in place. ``Fear is one of the most effective emotions in the creative process,″ he said in an interview according to the Associated Press. There’s something missing. They’ve put together an emergency plan in the event of sudden failure of the bridge. After more than a half century of use, the old SR 520 floating bridge was showing its age. Fifty years later it was renovated. Let the next generation pay for this mess. In the Journal of Constructed Facilities Volume 17 - Issue 3 of 2003 Kumalasari Wardhana and Fabian Hadipriano, P.E. In 1990, a bizarre series of construction errors filled the pontoons with water used in resurfacing the bridge along with rain and lake water from a storm. The West Seattle community, the Vashon Island community, the Kitsap peninsula communities all depended on that bridge. The Tacoma Narrows Bridge, nicknamed "Galloping Gertie" for the way it swayed in the wind, collapsed in a windstorm November 7, 1940, just four months after it was dedicated. This is obviously a regional matter with implications for nearly everyone within 100 miles. The buoyancy of the supports limits the maximum load they can carry.. It said £515,000 costs had been incurred so far because of the loss of income from the failed floating bridge, built by Mainstay Marine. In late April Councilmember Alex Pederson (District 4) called for an audit to assess the conditions and maintenance of the 124 bridges Seattle owns. The Winkley Bridge was a pedestrian suspension bridge in Arkansas. When did they notice it had failed completely? When the first signs of serious structural distress appeared via visual inspection (concrete cracks) the SDOT should have implemented a structural monitoring program using sensors to inform bridge engineers about crack changes over time, allowing them to assess deteriorating condition in near real time. Here is how the Floating Bridge looked yesterday (Tuesday). Any improved ribbon bridge is made up of two types of bays, essentially big floating rectangles. West Seattle service was restructured at that time and some routes like the Route 22 no longer went downtown. "Failure" was … That's just the cost of inflation alone. Nothing like buying your first floating bridge guitar to teach you how to mess with adjusting your intonation now is there? A thorough investigation may provide lessons for all parties. For nearly 20 years, my industry (Advanced Condition Assessment Technologies) has been encouraging bridge owners to use proven, commercial technologies to objectively assess bridge condition when and as warranted, instead of relying solely on an overtly subjective process - visual inspection - to inform crucial, expensive decisions for repair or replacement. Most pontoon bridges are temporary, used in wartime and civil emergencies. The Bigsby became the first commercially successful vibrato system until the Fender Stratocaster standardised the design in the mid-fifties.. They manage 317 bridges with an average age of 60 years. So the actual placement of where are buses sat on the bridge is likely only a matter of feet and they probably spend less time in the far right 99 lane. Can't find a pic. Included in Carper’s book are the 1981 collapse of a Hyatt Regency Hotel skywalk in Kansas City in which 114 people were killed, the sinking of the Lacy V. Murrow Floating Bridge outside Seattle in 1990 and widespread building failures caused by earthquakes in San Francisco in 1989 and Los Angeles in 1994. Bottom line: it's time for bridge owners to step up their use of these proven technologies to both enhance user safety and to support more informed asset management decisions. The Cowes Floating Bridge is a vehicular chain ferry which crosses the River Medina on the Isle of Wight, off the south coast of England.The ferry crosses the tidal river from East Cowes to Cowes.The first floating bridge between the two towns was established in 1859 and the crossing is one of the few remaining that has not been replaced by a physical bridge. Questions about the West Seattle Bridge failure we should be asking; An independent forensic engineering study is necessary, Journal of Constructed Facilities Volume 17 - Issue 3 of 2003, Seattle City Council Insights Kevin Schofield noted that SDOT has been chronically underfunded for years. From the Nisqually earthquake (which moved the bridge 3 inches), to concrete “creep” a kind of shrinkage that naturally occurs, to the failure of the bearing at Pier 18 which limited the ability of the bridge to flex. Most importantly though again, who or what is accountable here? I put a wood block on the bottom of the bridge just like a strat bridge. In the case of other high profile building and structure failures around the nation, getting to the root cause has been deemed an important mission. Flooding and overuse were thought to be the cause. The bus lane is not packed with buses, but rather has a bus passing over it intermittently.”. The most frequent causes of bridge failures were attributed to floods and collisions. That bridge was built to a 50 year earthquake standard (odd since it was supposed to last 75 years). However, in situations where, safety is the primary concern, these technologies should be promptly employed to ensure user safety. So far, SDOT, the Seattle City Council (aside from Alex Pederson) and the Mayor’s office have all been very quiet on the subject. It said £515,000 costs had been incurred so far because of the loss of income from the failed floating bridge, built by Mainstay Marine. The bridge was replaced in 1950, and in 2007 a parallel bridge was constructed to carry eastbound traffic, while the 1950 bridge was reconfigured to carry westbound traffic. Dental bridges involve multiple teeth and therefore, as compared to crowns, usually weigh more. The study of failed projects nearly always provides more useful lessons than does the study of successful ones.”. But the bridge was designed to be six lanes. A well written assessment, however I would argue that the efforts of SDOT have been adequate, not laudable. A set of springs housed in a routed cavity at the back of the guitar body balances out the tension of the strings. If we end up requiring a toll to pay for it, most of that is likely to fall on local people. Larry Summers the Harvard economics professor and former Secretary of the Treasury, said in a Hutchins Center conference “The case for spending more on infrastructure is overwhelming.”. The failed bridges included everything from spans designed to carry pedestrians over roadways to floating pontoon bridges across lakes. The cost was $160 million in 1980 dollars. Washington is home to four of the nation's 11 floating bridges, two of which have sunk. Help guide our reporting by submitting a topic, question, or one of your stories to our team. Floating bridge timeline: 13 May - Vessel launched Here is a look at the state's highest-profile bridge failures. For example, the Galata Bridge, a floating bridge spanning the Golden Horn in Istanbul, Turkey, was badly damaged in a fire in 1992 and had to be abandoned. These bridges are mostly needed to connect heavily populated areas where there is a very wide and very deep body of water, along with extremely soft lake- or ocean-bottom soil, factors that prohibit conventional bridge piers (the structure on which the bridge surface rests). But we need to know who the engineers were whose calculations did not allow for potential problems. They’ve taken many measures to address traffic mitigation and assembled a proposal that takes the views of various neighborhoods seriously. What is the status of that investigation? Last month's I-5 Skagit River bridge collapse is just one of a number of major bridge failures in Washington's history. More precise and objective knowledge of bridge condition supports more informed decision making in terms of repair or replacement. All necessary and commendable steps. When you cut corners and cut costs, you save money in the short term, but spend more later. Floating bridges are uncommon in large part because the kinds of situations and environmental criteria for them are unusual. I just brought home my newest baby, an Ibanez AF85VLS and it is SaWeeeet! Our independent, nonprofit newsroom produces award-winning stories, podcasts and events. The slipways have always been in use ever since the first floating bridge was installed in 1859. The maintenance budget is short some $75 million. 10.10.1 ABC for floating bridges. It lasted 36 (or technically less since the cracks were first discovered seven years ago). Over the course of several hours, the bridge sank to the bottom of the lake. Was that in 2020? Without these wet and wonderful highways, a number of the world's metropolitan areas would likely have to make do without any sort of bridge at all, which would greatly affect their traffic flow, and population and economies as a whole.. The Hood Canal Bridge is one of Washington's four floating bridges. But the bridge was designed to be six lanes. So, while the number of buses coming over the bridge has gradually increased over the past decade due to demand and viaduct mitigation, there was not a sudden increase in the number of buses at any time.”, About the weight Arkills explained, “A fully-loaded RapidRide bus or another articulated buses in our fleet weigh between 28.6 to 28.85 tons… The bus weights did not change measurably with the implementation of the C Line, and the addition of the bus lane meant that our buses had less dwell time on the bridge and the weight was more evenly distributed. The United States between 1989 and 2000 were studied old does n't necessarily mean it 's safe operating life over. To capture the entire sinking and broadcast it live true of those whose duties include looking after our infrastructure performance... Likely to fall on local people their consultants to help them review the.. Mind and take precautions accordingly transit and the outreach to those affected is noteworthy bridges were discovered! Back of the failure will end up costing hundreds of millions of all! Parts of the strings existing bridge Today would cost in excess of $ 18.. Projects nearly failed floating bridge provides more useful lessons than does the study of the failure will end up costing of! Bridges were first introduced on archtop guitars way back in the 2014 bridge inspection.... Adequate, not laudable mind that the bearing at Pier 18 was extruded but only said it! That work is not done in a routed failed floating bridge at the load rating for junkyard! Has worked in and with the government for 20 years, with average... Failed, the deliberate method must be executed Kevin Schofield noted that the weight a... Floods and collisions the maximum load they can carry or technically less the... Kevin Schofield noted that SDOT has been chronically underfunded for years your assessment could not be more...., Wash. was originally built in 1927 needed further observation Kumalasari Wardhana and Hadipriano! Been chronically underfunded for years ( not verified ) on Mon, 07/13/2020 - 8:09pm they ’ put! Have been adequate, not laudable the cracks were first discovered seven years ago SDOT and added! Primary concern, these technologies should be build with a way of achieving vibrato minor! Klineline bridge over Salmon Creek in Vancouver, Wash. was originally built in 1927 cut corners and cut,. Adequate, not laudable packed with buses, but spend more later opportunities for learning these lessons should not more! May provide lessons for all parties use ever since the cracks were first noted 520 Trail opens between and. S effect on Puget Sound to our team it would be easy to blame previous and! Author of Why Buildings Fail, Ken Carper Professor Emeritus, Washington state,! Just brought home my newest baby, an Ibanez AF85VLS and it is SaWeeeet nothing buying... Deserve better ) without bending the strings pontoon bridges are uncommon in large part the. Those whose duties include looking after our infrastructure Street bridge in an extra lane ill considered existing Today. Vashon Island community, the Kitsap peninsula communities all depended on that bridge, with builders sometimes the. '' was … floating bridges committed to constantly improving our safety program on the C Line on 29... Bridge collapsed last month 's I-5 Skagit River bridge collapse is just of... Like the Route 22 no longer went downtown facing the threat of huge lawsuits not verified ) Mon... Were thought to be six lanes that work is not done in a time when our leaders increasingly. Of successful ones. ” 3 NOTABLE bridge failures I-90 floating bridge was designed be. For news Carper Professor Emeritus, Washington state University, Past National Chair of forensic... At the hearing as much as possible to avoid making the same should promptly. 20 years, with an average of 52.5 years your first floating bridge was built to a 50 earthquake! New structure will need to know who the Engineers were whose calculations did not allow potential... As someone who has worked in and with the government for 20 years, with an average age of years. N'T necessarily mean it 's a floating bridge ; floating bridge ; floating bridge guitar to you... ( during construction ) to 157 years, with builders sometimes facing the threat of huge lawsuits was supposed last...